Sunday, September 8, 2013

Beowulf vs. Batman Essay


                The classic hero possesses strength, bravado, ethics and most importantly, fights evil. These characteristics apply to Beowulf and to a modern hero like Batman with slight modifications. Both of these heroes come from a completely different time period but that both have a great impact on their society. One of the most distinct similarities between these two heroes is the fact that they both don’t have superpowers, they use only their strength to defeat evil. Their differences lie behind their intentions of conquering evil.

                Though thoughts and opinions of a hero have altered through the years, both Beowulf and Batman possess similar qualities. They both execute a great deal of strength. Beowulf swam for seven straight days and fights multiple sea monsters. He also uses his robustness during the battle with Grendel and rips off Grendel’s arm with his bare hands. Batman, also single-handedly, fights gangs of criminals on numerous occasions in the movie, showing not only strength but endurance like Beowulf. Batman ethics show that he does not allow for murder unless it is absolutely necessary. If the criminals are not an immediate threat he will let them go. Beowulf shows this code of ethics as well in a conversation with Unferth. He says, “You murdered your own brothers, your own close kin. Words and bright wit won’t help your soul; you’ll suffer hell’s fire, Unferth, forever tormented. Beowulf would not harm a soul, unless it would harm those he loves, like the monsters surrounding the Danes. Lastly, they both prove themselves as heroes by defeating evil. When the enemy attacked, both were there to protect the innocent. Beowulf came and protected those in Herot by killing Grendel, and then killing Grendel’s mother. Batman also knows he must fight evil in Gotham City. He battles criminals on the street and eventually fights and destroys the joker.

                Though both Beowulf and Batman hold many similar qualities, they have differences as well. The main dissimilarities lie behind their intentions. Humility has become a desired trait in modern times today, whereas in Beowulf’s time self-confidence to the point of hauteur was a favorable attribute. Beowulf fights the monsters for praise and worthiness. On the other hand, Batman never reveals his identity when fighting criminals, therefore showing he is not looking for praise but rather protecting the innocent citizens out of the goodness of his heart and justice.

                For the most part characterization of heroes hasn’t change over the centuries. Comparing Beowulf to a more modern hero like Batman doesn’t have many exterior differences. They both use their strength to fight evil and protect those who do not deserve to be harmed.

4 comments:

  1. Bailey, The first thing I noticed when reading your essay was the use of the past weeks vocabulary! Before reading your essay I never thought to compare Batman to Beowulf, but after reading your essay I clearly see their similarities. One thing that could make your essay a little stronger would be to add more detail to your examples. Other then that I clearly understood every point you were making throughout the essay.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I really liked the examples you provided to show how these two characters are similar, especially the quote in paragraph 2. The only thing I would consider revising is the strength of your examples of how the two characters are different. Overall I thought it was a very well written essay.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I liked your examples and I thought you supported them well by offering snapshots of the text. If I had to choose something to improve on I would say that some of the sentences are a little choppy and might work better if combined into longer statements. Good work!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Good job using vocabulary! Also I liked how your essay was straightforward and easy to follow, with many specific examples from the text. If I had to suggest something I would say add a little more detail about the differences in the two societies. Good work Bay!

    ReplyDelete